Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
What’s New in Prism 4?
Advances in Curve Fitting
2
 
3
"Creates scientific graphs"
  • Creates scientific graphs
  • Performs basic biostatistics
  • Helps you organize your data
  • Fits curves with nonlinear regression
  • Helps you pick analyses and interpret results
  • Easy to learn
  • Efficient to use


4
New features in nonlinear regression
  • Confidence and prediction bands
  • Constraints
  • Fit only to selected range
  • Several standard curves at once
  • Define more complicated models. More parameters. More functions. Define different equations for different data sets.
  • Global fitting (shared parameters)
  • Comparing models. Easier. AICc or F test.
  • New book on nonlinear regression


5
 
6
 
7
 
8
New features in nonlinear regression
  • Confidence and prediction bands
  • Constraints
  • Fit only to selected range
  • Several standard curves at once
  • Define more complicated models. More parameters. More functions. Define different equations for different data sets.
  • Global fitting (shared parameters)
  • Comparing models. Easier. AICc or F test.
  • New book on nonlinear regression


9
 
10
New features in nonlinear regression
  • Confidence and prediction bands
  • Constraints
  • Fit only to selected range
  • Several standard curves at once
  • Define more complicated models. More parameters. More functions. Define different equations for different data sets.
  • Global fitting (shared parameters)
  • Comparing models. Easier. AICc or F test.
  • New book on nonlinear regression


11
 
12
New features in nonlinear regression
  • Confidence and prediction bands
  • Constraints
  • Fit only to selected range
  • Several standard curves at once
  • Define more complicated models. More parameters. More functions. Define different equations for different data sets.
  • Global fitting (shared parameters)
  • Comparing models. Easier. AICc or F test.
  • New book on nonlinear regression


13
 
14
New features in nonlinear regression
  • Confidence and prediction bands
  • Constraints
  • Fit only to selected range
  • Several standard curves at once
  • Define more complicated models. More parameters. More functions. Define different equations for different data sets.
  • Global fitting (shared parameters)
  • Comparing models. Easier. AICc or F test.
  • New book on nonlinear regression


15
New features in nonlinear regression
  • Confidence and prediction bands
  • Constraints
  • Fit only to selected range
  • Several standard curves at once
  • Define more complicated models. More parameters. More functions. Define different equations for different data sets.
  • Global fitting (shared parameters)
  • Comparing models. Easier. AICc or F test.
  • New book on nonlinear regression


16
What is Global Model-Fitting?
17
"Regular nonlinear regression minimizes the..."
  • Regular nonlinear regression minimizes the sum of the squared vertical distances between points and curve.
  • Global nonlinear regression minimizes the sum of the sum-of-squares for all data sets.
  • Only makes sense when all data sets are expressed in same units (or at least normalized to be comparable).
18
"Prism 4 would not have..."
  • Prism 4 would not have shared parameters if not for the help, and repeated nagging, of Arthur Christopoulos Dept. of Pharmacology, University of Melbourne … who also created initial drafts of many of these slides.
19
Global Model-Fitting
20
Incomplete Data Sets
21
Concentration-Response Curves
22
Concentration-Response Curves
23
Concentration-Response Curves
24
Concentration-Response Curves
25
 
26
Fitting Models
where the parameters you care about come from two or more data sets (not one).
27
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
28
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
29
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
30
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
31
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
32
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
33
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
34
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
35
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
36
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
37
Example 1: Radioligand Saturation Binding
38
Example 2: Homologous Competition Binding
39
Example 2: Homologous Competition Binding
40
Example 2: Homologous Competition Binding
41
Example 2: Homologous Competition Binding
42
In Prism 4
43
Example 2: Homologous Competition Binding
44
Example 2: Homologous Competition Binding
45
Example 2: Homologous Competition Binding
46
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
47
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
48
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
49
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
50
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
51
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
52
How to set constants with different values for each data set in Prism 4
53
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
54
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
55
Example 3: Agonist-Antagonist C/R Curve Analysis
56
Final Example – Kinetic Binding Curves
57
Final Example – Kinetic Binding Curves
58
Final Example – Kinetic Binding Curves
59
Final Example – Kinetic Binding Curves
60
Final Example – Kinetic Binding Curves
61
Global fitting
  • Lets you save time and get better results.
  • Three features in Prism 4 facilitate global fitting:
    • Share one or more parameters between data sets
    • Specify different equations for different data sets (<A> syntax)
    • Specify that one parameter in the equation gets its value from the column title of each data set. So a constant within each data set, but different values for different data sets. You can think of this as a second independent variable.
62
New features in nonlinear regression
  • Confidence and prediction bands
  • Constraints
  • Fit only to selected range
  • Several standard curves at once
  • Define more complicated models. More parameters. More functions. Define different equations for different data sets.
  • Global fitting (shared parameters)
  • Comparing models. Easier. AICc or F test.
  • New book on nonlinear regression


63
Not enough to compare sum-of-squares (goodness of fit)
  • More complicated model (more parameters) almost always fits better.
  • Two-site model fits better than one-site
  • Three-site model fits even better
  • So need to trade-off improvement in fit (lower SS) with more parameters (fewer df)
  • Two ways to do this: F test and AIC
64
F-Test: Standard Example.
Comparing fit of two models to one data set
65
F-Test (Extra Sum-Of-Squares Test)
66
Akaike’s Information Criterion
Comparing fit of two models to one data set
67
Akaike’s Information Criterion
Comparing fit of two models to one data set
68
Akaike’s Information Criterion
Comparing fit of two models to one data set
69
Akaike’s Information Criterion
Comparing fit of two models to one data set
70
F test or AIC?
  • F test:
  • If the simpler model were correct, what is the chance of obtaining data where the difference in sum-of-squares between the two models is as large or larger than you observed?
  • AICc:
  • How well do the data support each model? Which model is more likely to be correct? How much more likely?



71
F test or AIC?
  • F test:
  • Statistical hypothesis testing (familiar to many, null hypothesis, P value…)
  • Compares nested models only.
  • Requires threshold significance level (0.05)
  • Makes a decision so you don’t have to think.
  • Not straightforward to extend to three or more models.
  • Assumptions: Gaussian independent error….


72
F test or AIC?
  • AICc:
  • Information theory. Unfamiliar to many.
  • Compares nested, or unnested, models.
  • Easy to extend to three or more models.
  • Doesn’t make decision.
  • Tells you how well the data support each model.
  • Assumptions: Gaussian independent error….
73
F test or AIC?
  • If models not nested, use AIC.
  • If comparing three or more models, use AIC.
  • In all other cases (the vast majority) it is a matter of taste.
  • I prefer AIC, as it answers the question you care about: Which model is more likely to be correct and how much more likely?


74
Comparing Curves
75
Comparing Curves
76
Comparing Curves
77
How to answer?
  • Rephrase the question to compare models, with our without sharing.
78
Comparing Curves
79
Comparing Curves
80
Comparing Curves
81
Comparing Curves with F test
82
Comparing Curves with AICc
83
Comparing Parameters
84
Comparing Parameters
85
Comparing Parameters
86
Comparing Parameters
87
Comparing Parameters, with F test
88
Comparing Parameters, with AICc
89
New features in nonlinear regression
  • Confidence and prediction bands
  • Constraints
  • Fit only to selected range
  • Several standard curves at once
  • Define more complicated models. More parameters. More functions. Define different equations for different data sets.
  • Global fitting (shared parameters)
  • Comparing models. Easier. AICc or F test.
  • New book on nonlinear regression
90